A Report on Fatalities in Commercial Diving
Understanding and Mitigating Fatalities in Commercial Diving
Commercial diving is an essential, yet inherently dangerous, profession, with a notable risk of commercial diving fatalities. Divers perform critical underwater tasks supporting vital global industries, including offshore energy (oil, gas, wind), shipping, civil engineering, and aquaculture. While indispensable, the underwater environment presents extreme challenges. A detailed report by Professor Andy Woods from the Institute of Energy and Environmental Flows at the University of Cambridge examines historical data on fatalities and serious injuries in commercial diving, highlighting persistent risks and exploring pathways to improved safety.
Download the Full Report (PDF)
Key Findings: A High-Risk Profession
The report confirms that commercial diving ranks among the most hazardous occupations globally, with fatality rates historically far exceeding those in many other sectors.
Alarming Fatality Rates
Historical data paints a stark picture. Studies cited suggest rates ranging from 2-4 fatalities per 10,000 divers per year (UK HSE, 2010) to potentially higher figures like 11.2 (France, post-1991) or even 18.1 (US, 1998 study). These figures place the risk significantly above sectors like construction (estimated 12-24 times higher risk in the UK, 8-10 times in France) and vastly higher than general industry averages (potentially 40 times higher, per a 1998 US OSHA estimate).
Exceeding Tolerable Limits
The UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) defines a risk of 1 fatality in 1,000 per year for a worker as “intolerable.” Historical data suggests commercial diving risks have often approached or potentially exceeded this critical threshold, demanding significant mitigation efforts to prevent diving fatalities.
Beyond Individual Error
While immediate causes of diving accidents vary, the report highlights recurring underlying factors contributing to accidents in the diving operation. Analysis suggests that inadequate safety culture, poor management supervision, insufficient pre-dive planning, and incomplete hazard assessments are often significant contributors to diving accidents, rather than solely a lack of diver skill or experience. Indeed, data suggests fatalities occur across experience levels.
Serious, Life-Altering Injuries
The dangers extend beyond fatalities. Commercial divers face substantial risks of severe injuries, many related to pressure changes. These include:
- Decompression Sickness (DCS or “The Bends”): Nitrogen bubbles forming in tissues/bloodstream during ascent, causing pain, neurological damage, or worse.
- Arterial Gas Embolism (AGE): Air bubbles entering the bloodstream due to lung overexpansion during ascent can lead to a diving accident, potentially blocking blood flow to the brain or heart, often fatal underwater.
- Barotrauma: Injuries caused by pressure differences affecting air-filled body cavities (ears, sinuses, lungs, teeth) can lead to a commercial diving accident, potentially resulting in ruptured eardrums, collapsed lungs (pneumothorax), or tissue damage.
- Long-Term Health Issues: Conditions like dysbaric osteonecrosis (avascular necrosis or bone death) can develop due to pressure exposure in scuba divers, increasing fracture risk.
Common Causes of Diving Incidents
The underwater workplace presents unique and formidable hazards. The report identifies several recurring causes of fatal and serious incidents:
- Differential Pressure (Delta P): A major and often underestimated killer. Divers can be instantly trapped or pulled into underwater intakes, pipes, or structures where water flow creates a pressure difference. This accounts for a significant portion of incidents.
- Entanglement/Entrapment: Becoming snagged on ropes, nets, cables, wreckage, or underwater structures, preventing ascent or access to emergency gas.
- Equipment Failure: Critical malfunctions involving breathing apparatus (gas supply, regulators, masks), umbilical cords (air/comms lines), dive helmets, or buoyancy control devices.
- Gas Supply Issues: Running out of breathing gas, incorrect gas mixtures, or contaminated air leading to hypoxia, poisoning, or loss of consciousness.
- Environmental Hazards: Impacts with vessels or propellers, being struck or buried by falling objects, underwater explosions or burns (especially during welding/cutting), and hypothermia.
- Medical Events: Sudden cardiac arrest, stroke, or other medical emergencies occurring underwater, often exacerbated by exertion, pressure, or pre-existing conditions.
Pathways to Enhanced Safety
While risks are inherent, the report emphasizes that improvements are possible and necessary through a multi-faceted approach:
- Unyielding Adherence to Protocols: Strict, consistent application of established safety protocols (like those from HSE, OSHA, IMCA, ADCI) is paramount. This includes thorough pre-dive risk assessments, detailed planning, emergency preparedness, and vigilant supervision.
- Investing Proactively in Safety (ALARP): The “As Low As Reasonably Practicable” (ALARP) principle mandates that duty-holders must invest in safety measures unless the cost is “grossly disproportionate” to the risk reduction achieved. Given the high risks in the diving industry, this implies a substantial and ongoing commitment to training, advanced equipment, robust diving safety management systems, and potentially exploring safer alternatives. Older data suggested a risk-based investment benchmark could be in the range of £600-£2000 per diver per year, purely based on fatality risk value, in addition to standard safety costs.
- Leveraging Technology: Technology offers powerful tools to mitigate risks.
- Diverless Systems: Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs), Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs), and robotic systems can increasingly perform tasks like inspection, maintenance, hull cleaning, and surveys, removing the human from the hazardous environment entirely.
- Remote Hazard Detection: Technology can be used to identify dangers like pressure differentials before a diver enters the water.
- Continuous Improvement and Shared Learning: Robust incident reporting and investigation, coupled with transparent sharing of lessons learned across the industry globally, are vital for identifying emerging risks and refining best practices. The lack of a comprehensive, recent global database is noted as a hindrance.
- Training and Competency: Ensuring divers and surface support crews receive high-quality, recurrent training and maintain competency is fundamental.
Gain a comprehensive understanding of the risks, historical context, and future directions for safety in commercial diving.
Download the full University of Cambridge report for in-depth analysis, detailed data, incident examples, and safety recommendations.
Download the Full Report (PDF)
Contact us to learn more about our innovative diverless solutions.
